| Platinum | Junkyard Cafe |
| Gold | Topper's Pizza |
| Silver | Fatte's |
| Bronze | The East Coast Pizza Company Inc. |
| Top Pick | Big Z |
| Top Pick | Chi Chi's Pizza |
| Top Pick | Mod Pizza |
| Top Pick | Rock & Roll Pizza |
| Top Pick | Round Table Pizza |
| Top Pick | Slice House By Tony Gemignani |